CCAMLR

The current management strategy of the Ross Sea Antarctic toothfish fishery in an MSY mode is to target the oldest, largest, most fecund fish, theoretically to increase the number and growth rate of smaller fish. The literature is reviewed to reveal why this strategy has failed in the past for fisheries taking long-lived, late maturing benthic fish. Not only have there been ecological effects of removing  large fish but such fisheries, in a process called longevity overfishing, has selected against those fish that natural processes have selected for.

We report the analyses of a dataset spanning 39 years of near-annual fishing for Dissostichus mawsoni in McMurdo Sound, Antarctica, 1972–2011. Data on total length, condition and catch per unit effort (CPUE) were derived from the > 5500 fish caught, the large majority of which were measured, tagged and released. Contrary to expectation, the length frequency of the McMurdo Sound catch was dominated by fish in the upper two-thirds of the overall distribution exhibited in the industrial catch for the Ross Sea shelf. Fish length and condition increased from the early 1970s to the early 1990s and then decreased. Fish length positively correlated with Ross Sea ice extent in early spring, a relationship possibly caused by more ice encouraging larger fish to move farther south over the shelf and into the study area. Fish condition positively correlated with the amount of open water in the Ross Sea during the previous summer (Feb), perhaps reflecting greater availability of prey with the higher productivity that more open water brings. Decreasing fish size corresponds to the onset of the fishery, which targets the large individuals. CPUE was constant through 2001 and then decreased dramatically. We hypothesize that this decrease is related to the industrial fishery, which began in the 1996–97 austral summer, and concentrates effort over the ice-free Ross Sea continental slope. As a result of limited prey choices and close coupling among mesopredators of the region, Antarctic toothfish included, the fishery appears to be dramatically altering the trophic structure of the Ross Sea.

Foraging events and related trends in numbers of Type-B and -C killer whales (Orcinus orca) are reported for the vicinity of Ross Island, Ross Sea, Antarctica, between 2002 and 2010. Updating an earlier report, the frequency of sightings and the number of individuals per sighting of Ross Sea killer whales (Type-C; RSKWs), a fishing-eating ecotype, has continued to decrease in a pattern coincident with a decrease in the number and size of an important prey: Antarctic toothfish (Dissostichus mawsoni). Increasingly rare, large fish are much more energetically dense and may also be socially important to the whales, a relationship with potential parallels to that known between well-studied fish-eating killer whales and large Chinook salmon (Oncorhynchus tshawytscha) in the northeast Pacific. In contrast, the prevalence of the larger, mammal-eating Type-B killer whales has not changed in the southern Ross Sea study area. Predation events by Type-B killer whales involving Weddell seals (Leptonychotes weddellii), interest in large penguins, such as emperors (Aptenodytes forsteri), and lack of interest in small penguins, such as Adélies (Pygoscelis adeliae), are presented. In the case of both killer whale forms, the progressive seasonal breakup of fast ice in large bays bordering the Ross Sea likely provides reliable, enhanced foraging opportunities as prey are exposed one area at a time during summer. Given the apparent relationship between RSKW prevalence and the availability of large toothfish, we speculate that the current management strategy of Antarctic toothfish in the Ross Sea region threatens current population levels of RSKW.